GOOD crimps are at least as good as soldering, both continuity-wise and strength-wise. That is the part of the reason that the connections in aircraft are made using crimps. However, GOOD splices require the correct crimp tool and correctly sized connectors. And most people use pliers and over-sized connectors, which results in really crappy connections.
Most people can produce an acceptable solder joint with only a bit of practice.
So I would argue that while crimping CAN result in the better connection it often does not, and most people should stick to soldering. Soldering also has the potential benefit of resulting in a more compact splice. Which a real benefit in places like under the dash when you want to re-bundle wires. And you don't need a drawer-full of different size connectors --- solder is pretty much "one size fits all".
Personally, I do use crimps, but I spent $100 for a used pro-grade crimp tool.
Last edited by Noisy Crow; 02-15-2012 at 10:41 PM.
2008 Carbon Gray GT Sedan 5 Speed
so can we agree that for something like $30, the extension cable is a good idea and idiot proof...as well as cost effective? lol
MSpeed Tuning & Diagnostics - The Street Lab is always OPEN FOR BUSINESS
All Powder & Ceramic Coating @ Quy's Coating . Tires and Wheels @ Simply Tire . Wraps by mleblond @ Seche Media . Dyno'd @ Advance Power House . Professionally Serviced by Jimmy @ Street Performance . Signature Pic by PCLoadLetter . Street Tuned by myself .
"It is amazing how many drivers, even at the Formula One Level, think that the brakes are for slowing the car down." -- Mario Andretti
Never reliable eh, they why the hell does are solder joints not allowed in standard electrical practise. Not reliable when the crimp connector is heat made of a weather sealing and heat rated material. Not to mention how that you extended those shielded wires with solder how did you extend the shield. When the HELL have you ever seen sheilded MAF wires on a modern Mazda or any car for that matter. That POS 240's computer could barely tell the difference between 0.1V unlike modern Mazdas. Further more why would MAF wires be shielded in the first place, its not Hall effect tranducer, they are resistive type transducers. Guess what radio and electromagnetic waves don't effect resistance. Even on that POS 240, your extra resistance from soler just made the car run a leaner/richer depending on the signal, so of course it would work just fine the car was ****ed to begin with.
The next time you want to say my soldering sucks lets keep in mind who here has a 309A, I doubt it's you. Soldering is now mainly only used in plumbing. Since you like working on POS cars and love solder, I guess I know what you do for a living.
Want to work on your car but not sure how, send me a PM. Learn the way of Nator.
I trust butt connectors with my life yeah. I butt connect the piss out of the trucks at work. They go through much harsher conditions than cars do and on a daily basis. If they're good for a $100 000 + rig, its good enough for my car! haha
back on topic, the patch in leads are nice, i woudda like to have had em.
back on topic...
Adam - Kitchener, Ontario.
Far Far West O'l G! Proud Owner of the Whop-Toboggan Rice Bomb!
Ive never crimped in my life. I actually look at crimps and say "what a cheap job". If you know how to solder, your readings wouldnt get messed up. Your goal is to use the least bit of solder possible, while creating a solid connection. The signal will stay the same in most cases, unless you're overloading the solder to the point where you've doubled the gauge of your wire. By that time, you've taken the flexibility out of your wire which will easily corrode and deteriorate (sp?) the insulation. I used to make 02 wire extensions for a while, never once have i had a complaint.
Simply put, it must be damnnear perfect connection with minimal usage of solder. Too much heat causes too many problems.
Just my 2C.
____________________________________
2011 Celestial Mica Blue Mazda 3 GS Sport
2.5L 6 Speed Manual
DC Sports Intake, 5.5K Morimoto Retrofit HID kit, Sure Motorsports RMM
Enkei Wheels,R40 lug nuts, ISC N1 coilovers, Corksport short shifter, CS Rear sway bar
Ebay front strut bar, Custom magnaflow axleback w/ 4" tips, Style M front lip
Crimps are used as the industry standard, they are faster and more reliable then a soldered connection. I don't think they look cheap they look like a connection. Not to mention with crimps you get many different options of connectors.
I can't imagine having to cut or splice wires (or modify the sheet metal/plastic) every time I wanted to add something. My car would be swiss cheese and like someone said earlier, it's much nicer to be able to easily reverse everything and and also for troubleshooting.
So did you ever figure out if they made Mazda 3 specific o2 sensor extensions?
2008 Mazda 3s Touring sedan: Hypertech MESPP, Aasco flywheel, Medieval lightweight pulleys, 60mm throttle body, track pipe, Cosworth intake filter, OEM BBK (Ms3 front & Mz5 rear brakes), Goodridge SSBBL, Koni FSD, OEM '04-06 16" Mz3 alloy wheels, staggered Continental ExtremeContact DW summer tires (225/50/16 front & 205/55/16 rear), Morimoto/Xtreme/Lamin-x HID 5,000k headlights & 4,300k fog lights, OEM LED tail lights, OEM heated side view mirrors, OEM leather seats, OEM JDM leather armrest, OEM '04-06 leather shift knob, OEM '04-06 piano black dash trim/deco panel, aluminum HVAC knobs, Wheelskins leather steering wheel wrap, Corksport interior LEDs, LED smoked side markers & 3rd brake light, OEM + FIAMM + PIAA + Hella horns, Optima RedTop, OEM spin-on oil filter, Eneos 5W-20, Amsoil 75W-90 GL-4, ATE Super Blue/Type 200 Amber